What is your review of No Such Thing (2001 movie)?
"No Such Thing" (2001) is a film directed by Hal Hartley, known for his avant-garde style, which often blends quirky humor with serious themes. This movie is a modern retelling of "Beauty and the Beast," set against a backdrop of contemporary paranoia and media sensationalism. Here's a breakdown of the film:
Plot and Themes
The story revolves around Beatrice, a young reporter played by Sarah Polley, who encounters a foul-mouthed, immortal monster (Robert John Burke) living in isolation off the Icelandic coast. The monster, tired of his indestructible life, seeks death and enlists Beatrice's help to find a scientist who might be able to end his existence. The film explores themes of media manipulation, the search for meaning, and the clash between natural and urban environments.
Performances and Cinematography
Robert John Burke delivers a standout performance as the monster, bringing depth and complexity to the character. Helen Mirren also shines as the ruthless news executive, embodying the cynicism of modern media. The film's cinematography, particularly the Icelandic landscapes, is breathtaking and adds to the film's visual appeal.
Reception and Criticism
Reactions to "No Such Thing" have been mixed. Some viewers appreciate its quirky humor and the surreal interactions between Beatrice and the monster, while others find it disjointed and lacking in coherence. Critics like Roger Ebert have panned the film for its shapelessness and lack of clear direction, feeling that it fails to deliver on its promising elements5. However, some fans of Hal Hartley see it as a misunderstood masterpiece, noting its nods to influential directors like Jean-Luc Godard and its exploration of paranoia and media culture2.
Overall Assessment
While "No Such Thing" showcases Hartley's unique style and features strong performances, it struggles with narrative coherence and genre identity. It may appeal to fans of experimental cinema and those interested in exploring themes of media critique and existential longing, but it may not satisfy viewers seeking a more traditional narrative experience.
In summary, "No Such Thing" is a visually striking and thematically intriguing film that, despite its flaws, offers a unique viewing experience for those open to avant-garde storytelling.